By Fannie Lakoubay and Conner Williams via ArtNet News
At the end of the 1940s, Pablo Picasso (Spanish,
1881–1973) started creating ceramic works. At the time, Picasso spent his
summers on the Cote d'Azur in the South of France. Following earlier trips to
the Riviera, where he was inspired by the clarity of the light and the bright
Mediterranean colors, the artist visited Vallauris for the annual pottery
exhibition in 1946. Impressed by the quality of the Madoura works,
he was introduced to the owners, Suzanne and
Georges Ramié, who welcomed him into their workshop, and gave him access to all
the tools and resources he needed to express his creativity with ceramics. In
exchange, the Ramié family would produce and sell his ceramic work. This
collaboration with the local ceramicists spanned 25 years.
Picasso went on to create clay pieces throughout the last
years of his life. He initially found that working with clay was a relaxing
summer respite from the more strenuous demands of painting. He began with
simple utilitarian objects, such as plates and bowls. He then proceeded to
create more ambitious forms, such as pitchers and vases, where the handles
became facial or anatomical parts of the animal depicted. The subjects are very
creative and playful, and include Greek mythological figures, animal shapes,
such as owls and fishes, corrida scenes, and face motifs, among others.
This experience with clay was also a success for Picasso's
personal life, as he met Jacqueline Roque at the Madoura factory in 1953, who
would become his second wife in 1961.
What is the state of the auction market for Picasso
ceramics?
Over the past 10 years, the market for Picasso ceramics has
steadily grown, with seasoned collectors and new buyers alike vying for
Picasso's editioned and unique ceramics at auction. This market is stable, with
a steady high sell-through rate around 89% (87% in 2004, 89% in 2005, 87% in
2011, and 90% in 2012), and prices that are still lower than the rest of
Picasso's work. The broad range of estimates and sales prices help make this
market attractive to many collectors, but also explain the high average sales
prices, which are skewed by a few exceptional pieces. In the previous two
years, more than 60 exceptional ceramic works sold for over US$100,000: 34 in 2011
and 29 in 2012 (vs. six in 2004 and 2005).
About 50 years ago, when Picasso began creating ceramics in
collaboration with the Madoura Pottery workshop, he intended the pieces to be
accessible and affordable. As such, he created some works in editions of 500 or
more, and made them available for purchase directly from the workshop. Today,
Picasso's ceramic works are still readily accessible, available at auction, in
art galleries, and in the private market. Contributing to the availability of
these works is the current demand for them, which has steadily grown over the
past 10 years. This is the result of a number of factors.
First, the general rise of the Picasso market has
contributed to the availability of these works. Today, Picasso remains one of
the highest-grossing artists at auction, with a total sales value of
US$335,264,574 in 2012, and US$411,503,575 thus far in 2013. Second, the
increase in the market for Picasso originals has resulted in a number of buyers
being “priced out." Thus, a number of these ceramic works have replaced
the desire for more costly and sought-after unique paintings, drawings, and
sculpture.
The affordability of Picasso ceramics has long been
maintained by major auction houses. Because of the large catalogue of Picasso
ceramics produced—over 600 wares in a 25-year span—it has not been difficult to
source Picasso ceramics for auction. This has resulted in their pricing at
fairly modest estimates, which creates competition and often yields results
above high estimates. These above-high-estimate results have naturally earned
the attention of other Picasso ceramic collectors, who in turn may become
consignors in future auctions. For major auction houses, sourcing these works
is not difficult. In fact, many houses like Christie's
and Sotheby's
may limit the number of works they offer in each sale, whether it is a prints
and multiples sale or an Impressionist and Modern Art sale, where these works
are generally sold. Because there is less competition for Picasso ceramics,
auction houses have been able to bring the pieces to auction at relatively low
estimates, with the exception of the unique, rare, or large ceramics.
Major auction houses such as Bonhams or
Sotheby's regularly dedicate one part of their Modern Art sales to this category
of works. Recently, Sotheby's London hosted a Prints & Multiples—Old
Master, Modern & Contemporary sale on September 17, 2013, which
included exceptional Picasso ceramics (lots 134 to 242), of which, 69 sold, for
a total sales revenue of US$958,000. Bonhams Knightsbridge sold 15 Picasso
ceramics on October 23, 2013 in their Impressionist and Modern Art sale,
for a revenue of US$103,476.
Exclusive sales dedicated to Picasso ceramics have become
increasingly popular over the past few years, and these have certainly
contributed to the perception of a growing market. Christie's South Kensington
held a sale in June 2012, entirely dedicated to the Madoura Collection of
Picasso ceramics, which had an exceptional 100% sell-through rate for the 500
lots in the sale, with a total sales volume of US$12,584,141, or 58% of the
total Picasso ceramics sales volume in 2012. Results like this have called into
question the current approach to pricing ceramics. Are the major auction houses
pricing works too low? Are private collectors' investments not being properly
protected by offering up their ceramics at lower-than-average prices? Or is
this strategy of pricing works at low and desirable estimates an auction house
tradition that is working, or even growing the Picasso ceramics market?
